Logo Substack

Our review of Our Substack review: should you launch your B2B newsletter on this platform?

The paid newsletter launched in 30 minutes, for 10% of your revenue.

Salesdorado
4.2 /5
1 test
G2
4.3 /5
17 reviews
Trustpilot
1.4 /5
182 reviews
Weighted average 3.52/5 3 combined reviews
Price
Free, then a 10% commission on revenue

The verdict in 30 seconds

Substack is probably the best tool for launching a paid B2B newsletter without technical skills. Publishing, email, payments and community for a 10% commission: a fair deal to get started, with a 30-minute launch and a discovery network that brings in subscribers. But the commission becomes painful once the business takes off, and converting free subscribers into paying ones remains hard.

+ What we liked
  • Ultra-fast launch: in 30 minutes, your publication is online. No server setup, no theme to choose, no plugin to install. You write, you publish.
  • Zero cost to start: the platform is free as long as you don't monetise. You can build an audience of 10,000 subscribers without spending a cent, since the commission only applies to paid revenue.
  • A powerful discovery network: 40% of new free subscriptions come from the Substack network, recommendations, Notes and the Reader app. For a creator starting from zero, that's a considerable advantage over a standalone blog.
  • Full exportability: you can export your subscriber list, your archives and your payment data at any time. No lock-in: if you decide to leave, you leave with your audience.
  • Editorial independence: no ads, no algorithms dictating what you must publish to be visible. Your relationship with your readers belongs to you.
  • An all-in-one infrastructure: blog, newsletter, payments and community in a single platform, where you would otherwise need WordPress, Mailchimp, Stripe and a community tool. For non-technical people, the time saved is huge.
− The downsides
  • The 10% commission: at €5,000 in monthly revenue, you hand €500 a month to Substack, or €6,000 a year, on top of Stripe fees. A self-hosted stack would spare you this commission.
  • Limited SEO: publications have good domain authority, but technical control, custom tags, URL structure, loading speed, is fairly restricted. If SEO is at the heart of your acquisition, WordPress remains superior.
  • An overly minimalist editor: no advanced layout, no custom widgets. It's a deliberate choice, but some creators will feel limited in their visual expression.
  • Converting free to paid is hard: field feedback shows rates often below 2%. Substack makes the payment mechanics easier, but doesn't solve the fundamental problem, convincing readers to pay.
  • Dependence on an American platform: servers in the United States, a company subject to US law. For organisations sensitive to data sovereignty or strict GDPR compliance, it's a point to watch.
  • The podcast and video features remain basic compared with dedicated platforms: if either is at the heart of your strategy, you'll need additional tools.

Who it is for

★ Go for it if...

Freelancers, consultants and experts who want to test a paid newsletter with no upfront investment, and publish their first post in under an hour with no technical skills. An excellent choice if you're starting from zero and counting on the discovery network to win your first subscribers, if you accept the 10% commission in exchange for simplicity, or if you're running a side editorial project: founder newsletter, industry column, niche media. Also relevant for an independent journalist seeking editorial and financial independence.

⌘ Skip it if...

Look elsewhere if you already generate several thousand euros in monthly revenue, as the 10% commission then becomes painful. Look elsewhere too if you need advanced marketing automation, if SEO is at the heart of your acquisition, WordPress offering far greater control, if you're an SME or mid-sized company that wants to integrate the newsletter into an existing marketing stack, or if strict GDPR compliance and data sovereignty are non-negotiable.

Scores per criterion

  • Overall rating 4.2
  • Ease of use 4.6
  • Monetisation potential 3.7
  • Value for money 3.4

The tool in detail

Substack after real-world use: feature scope, integrations, pricing and concrete limits.

50 million active subscriptions, writers earning seven-figure incomes and a simple promise: let independent writers and podcasters share their content directly with their audience and make money by offering subscriptions. On paper, Substack has everything going for it.

Is Substack really the El Dorado of B2B content creators, or an inbound marketing tool that mostly benefits those who already have a massive audience? We analysed this newsletter tool in depth to give an honest opinion, far from the fans’ praise and the bad-faith criticism.

Substack home page

Substack: what is it exactly?

Substack is a subscription publishing platform, launched in 2017 in San Francisco by Chris Best, Hamish McKenzie and Jairaj Sethi. The founding idea: let creators monetise their audience directly, with no advertising middleman and no technical skills.

In practice, Substack brings together in a single platform what would otherwise take several tools:

  • A blog, like WordPress.
  • An emailing service, like Mailchimp or Brevo.
  • A payment system, like Stripe.
  • Community features.

The figures speak for themselves: 50 million active subscriptions, 5 million of them paid. The top creators earn seven-figure annual revenues.

Audience and revenue statistics displayed by Substack

Substack’s positioning rests on three pillars:

  • Radical simplicity: creating a publication takes less than 30 minutes. The editor is deliberately minimalist, so the creator focuses on the content, not on the tech.
  • Total independence: no ads, no algorithms dictating visibility. The creator owns their subscriber list and can export it at any time. No lock-in.
  • An aligned business model: Substack only makes money if you do, with a 10% commission on paid revenue. No fixed fees, no monthly subscription to use the platform.
Salesdorado’s take
Substack’s model is clever: free to start, commission only on success. It removes the barrier to entry and aligns interests. But careful, a 10% commission is still 10%. In the long run and at significant volume, the bill can get steep.

Substack’s key features

Multichannel publishing

The main feature lets you publish on three channels at once: the web, with a post reachable at a substack.com URL, email, sent automatically to all your subscribers, and the Substack Reader mobile app.

Substack Reader mobile app

For each post, you choose the access level:

  • Free: open to all subscribers, to build your audience and show your expertise.
  • Paid: reserved for paying subscribers, this is your premium content, the one that justifies the subscription.
  • Paid preview: free subscribers see an excerpt, with a call to action to upgrade to a paid subscription. A good compromise to make them want more.
Adding images in the Substack editor

The text editor is deliberately minimalist: images, links, quotes, basic formatting in bold, italics and lists. No advanced layout features, no custom widgets. It’s a deliberate choice, which forces you to focus on content rather than form.

Adding buttons to a Substack post
Special elements you can insert in a Substack post

Podcasts and videos

Substack isn’t limited to text. The platform lets you host podcasts and distribute them to all the major platforms, Apple Podcasts and Spotify in particular, in a few clicks. Episodes can be free or reserved for paying subscribers.

Podcast management in Substack

On the video side, you can import videos or record them directly in your posts. Here too, restricting them to paying subscribers is possible. This feature remains basic, though, compared with dedicated video platforms such as YouTube or Vimeo.

Video embedded in a Substack post
Salesdorado’s take
The podcast and video features are a welcome extra, but don’t expect professional production tools. Substack remains first and foremost a writing platform. If podcasts or video are at the heart of your strategy, you’ll probably need additional tools.

The recommendations network: Substack’s secret weapon

It may be Substack’s least obvious advantage, but it’s one of the most powerful. And it’s what really sets the platform apart from a simple blog with a newsletter bolted on.

The principle is simple: you recommend other publications to your subscribers, and other creators do the same for you. When a reader subscribes to a newsletter, Substack suggests other similar publications, potentially including yours.

Recommendations network between Substack publications

The figures speak for themselves: according to Substack, 40% of new free subscriptions and 15 to 20% of paid subscriptions come from this mechanism.

Publication suggestions at sign-up on Substack

For a creator starting from zero, it’s a really big advantage:

  • On a classic blog, you have to generate 100% of your traffic yourself: SEO, social media, advertising, partnerships.
  • On Substack, part of the acquisition is provided by the ecosystem. The experience of Marie Vandoorne, presented below, confirms it: 150 publications recommended her work, bringing her more than 2,000 subscribers with no direct marketing effort.

Obviously, it’s not magic. To be recommended, you first have to recommend. And for other creators to notice you, you have to be active on the platform: comment on their posts, interact on Notes, build connections. It’s a real time investment, but it can pay off big when you play the game.

Built-in monetisation

The payment system is handled entirely by Substack via Stripe. You have nothing to set up on the technical side.

Setting up paid subscriptions in Substack

The pricing options are flexible:

  • Monthly or annual subscriptions: you set your prices freely, with a minimum of $5 per month or $30 per year.
  • Founding member: a premium tier, at the price you set, for readers who want to support your work more.
  • Annual discount: typically 10 to 20% off, to encourage long-term commitment.
  • Multi-currency payment: your readers pay in their local currency, by bank card, Apple Pay, Google Pay, and local methods in Europe such as SEPA direct debit, iDEAL or Bancontact.
  • Paywalls and previews: advanced tools to convert free readers. You can set a free preview of your paid posts, reserve comments for paying subscribers, or give gradual access to your archives.

Substack pricing: how much does it really cost?

The commission model

Substack’s business model is simple and transparent: the platform is free, whatever your number of subscribers, as long as you don’t monetise. As soon as you turn on paid subscriptions, Substack takes 10% of your revenue.

Breakdown of the commissions taken by Substack

On top of that come the Stripe fees. For a French account, count 1.5% plus €0.25 per payment on standard European cards, and 0.7% in Stripe Billing fees on recurring subscriptions. Premium cards (2.8%) and non-European cards (3.15%) cost more. All in all, count on roughly 12% in deductions, plus €0.25 per payment.

Component Percentage On a €100 payment
Substack commission 10% €10.00
Stripe fees (standard European card) 1.5% + €0.25 €1.75
Stripe Billing fees 0.7% €0.70
Total deducted About 12.5% €12.45
Creator net About 87.5% €87.55

Careful, the €0.25 fixed fee weighs much more heavily on small amounts. On a €5 subscription, you lose about 17% of the payment. That’s an argument for pushing the annual subscription, which only triggers these fees once a year.

On the reader side, Substack adds no fees on web payments. Subscriptions taken out in the iOS app can, however, cost more, to cover Apple’s commission: you choose whether or not to pass it on. The only other possible cost: $50 one time to use your own domain name.

Revenue simulations

Here’s what you can expect in net revenue, depending on your number of paying subscribers and your monthly price:

Paying subscribers At €5 per month At €10 per month At €15 per month
50 About €207 net per month About €427 net per month About €646 net per month
100 About €414 net per month About €853 net per month About €1,292 net per month
200 About €828 net per month About €1,706 net per month About €2,584 net per month
500 About €2,070 net per month About €4,265 net per month About €6,460 net per month
1,000 About €4,140 net per month About €8,530 net per month About €12,920 net per month

Calculated on the basis of monthly payments by standard European card.

The Substack model is perfect for getting started: zero upfront investment, you only pay on success. But as your business grows, the commission becomes a significant cost item.

Let’s take a concrete example: you generate €5,000 per month in subscription revenue. Substack takes €500 per month, or €6,000 per year. At that level, a self-hosted stack, WordPress or Ghost plus Brevo or Mailchimp plus Stripe, would cost a few hundred euros per year at most. The Stripe fees, for their part, are due in both cases: what you save is indeed the 10% commission.

Salesdorado’s take
The tipping point is generally around €2,000 to €3,000 per month in recurring revenue. Below that, Substack’s simplicity is well worth the 10%. Above it, it becomes rational to consider migrating to a solution that takes a smaller commission. But careful: migrating an audience is never trivial.

Field feedback: the reality of Substack

Substack’s marketing figures are impressive. But what about a French B2B creator starting from almost zero? Marie Vandoorne’s experience offers a brutally honest look at the reality.

Marie Vandoorne's Substack publication

The raw figures after one year

  • Subscribers: from 41 to 4,620, a 112-fold increase.
  • Paying subscribers: a peak at 50, then a plateau.
  • Net revenue: €903.50 over the whole year.
  • Free-to-paid conversion rate: about 1%.

The real time investment

  • Launch phase, 4 months: 8 hours a day of intensive work, between writing, Notes, comments on other publications, networking and promotion.
  • Cruising phase: one post a week, or about 4 to 6 hours of work per week.

The key lessons

  • Growth isn’t magic. The 4,620 subscribers weren’t acquired passively. They’re the result of relentless work on Notes, comments and cross-recommendations. Substack provides the tools, but you do the work.
  • Monetisation is hard. 50 paying subscribers out of 4,620 is a conversion rate of about 1%, at the low end of what’s observed for B2B newsletters. Converting free readers into paying customers remains the main challenge, with or without Substack.
  • Consistency isn’t negotiable. Publishing every week for a year was the key retention factor. Creators who publish erratically see their audience erode quickly.
  • The Substack network is powerful. 150 publications recommended Marie’s work, bringing her more than 2,000 subscribers. It’s a real growth lever, but one that requires actively cultivating your network on the platform.
Statistics dashboard of a Substack publication
Salesdorado’s take
This field feedback perfectly illustrates our position: Substack is an excellent tool for launching and testing a paid newsletter. But it’s not an automatic cash machine. Success depends largely on your ability to produce quality content, distribute it actively and convert a free audience into paying customers. Substack makes the process easier, it doesn’t replace it.

Substack versus the alternatives: which tool should you choose?

Substack isn’t the only option for launching a paid newsletter. Here’s how it stacks up against the main alternatives.

Substack and Ghost

Ghost is often presented as the professional alternative to Substack. It’s an open source platform that offers much more control over design, SEO and integrations.

Its advantages: no commission on revenue, you only pay for hosting and Stripe fees; total control over design and SEO; self-hosting possible for complete sovereignty; an interface available in several languages.

Its drawbacks: it requires technical skills or managed hosting. With the vendor, paid subscriptions start with the Publisher plan, at $29 per month for 1,000 members, a price that rises with your audience. Ghost also offers cross-recommendations and a publication directory, but without the firepower of the Substack network: you’re largely on your own to build your audience. And the setup is more complex than a simple Substack account.

Our verdict: Ghost is better for creators who have technical skills, or the budget to delegate, and who want total control. Substack is preferable for those who want to start fast and benefit from the discovery network.

Substack and Brevo

Brevo is a French email marketing solution, which can be combined with a WordPress blog to build a newsletter stack.

Its advantages: a French solution, with native GDPR compliance and support in six languages, English included; competitive pricing, with a free plan of up to 300 emails per day; advanced marketing automation, workflows, scoring and segmentation; and integration with CRM and marketing tools.

Its drawbacks: you need a separate blog, WordPress or Ghost, for web publishing; there’s no built-in payment system, so you have to add Stripe; the tool is less community-oriented than Substack; and the setup is more complex, with several tools to make work together.

Our verdict: Brevo is preferable for SMEs that need advanced marketing automation and want a French solution. Substack is better suited to individual creators looking for simplicity.

Substack and the Mailchimp plus WordPress stack

The classic stack for creating a newsletter: WordPress for the blog, Mailchimp for emailing, Stripe for payments.

Its advantages: total control over each component; optimised SEO with WordPress; a variable but potentially very low cost; and a huge ecosystem of plugins and integrations.

Its drawbacks: the complexity of setup and maintenance; several tools to manage, several invoices, several interfaces; technical skills required, or a budget to delegate; and no built-in discovery network.

Our verdict: this stack is better for established creators who already generate significant revenue and want to optimise their costs. Substack is preferable for testing and launching quickly.

Try Substack risk-free
The best way to find out if Substack is right for you is to try it. Creating a publication is free, and you only pay a commission if you generate revenue. Launch your publication, publish a few posts, and see if the tool suits you. You can always migrate to Ghost or another solution later: Substack lets you export all your data.

Specs

Vendor
Substack, launched in 2017 in San Francisco by Chris Best, Hamish McKenzie and Jairaj Sethi
Volume
50 million active subscriptions, 5 million of them paid
Publishing
Simultaneous on the web, by email and in the Substack Reader app, with free, paid or paid preview access
Text editor
Deliberately minimalist: images, links, quotes, bold, italics and lists. No advanced layout or widgets
Podcasts and videos
Hosting and distribution to Apple Podcasts and Spotify, import or recording of videos, can be restricted to paying subscribers
Discovery network
Cross-recommendations between publications, Notes, suggestions at sign-up. 40% of free subscriptions and 15 to 20% of paid ones according to the vendor
Monetisation
Monthly, annual or founding member subscriptions via Stripe, annual discount, multi-currency, SEPA direct debit, paywalls and previews
Commission
10% on paid revenue, plus Stripe fees: 1.5% + €0.25 per payment on standard European cards and 0.7% for Stripe Billing, i.e. about 12% plus €0.25 per payment
Portability
Export of the subscriber list, archives and payment data at any time
Limits
Restricted technical control over SEO, no advanced marketing automation, hosting in the United States
Extra costs
Custom domain name: $50 one time. iOS in-app purchases cost more if you choose to pass on Apple's commission

3 alternatives to know

If Substack isn't the right fit, here's what we'd look at if we were you.

  • Logo Kit
    Kit 4.6 Free up to 10,000 subscribers, then $89 per month for 5,000 subscribers
    The email marketing software built by a creator for creators.
    See review
  • Logo Brevo
    Brevo 5.0 From 49€/month
    The most powerful European email marketing tool for the price
    See review
  • Logo MailerLite
    MailerLite 4.7 Free up to 2,500 emails per month, then €11 per month
    European email marketing, simple and affordable, with its data hosted in Europe.
    See review

Verified user reviews

Reviews collected through our partner program, work emails verified.

★ No reviews yet

Do you use Substack every day? Be the first to share your review with the Salesdorado community.

Share my review

Share my review of Substack

All reviews are checked and the work email verified before publishing. Just 5 minutes.

★ Work email required
Your rating *
Click to rate (0.5 step)

By submitting, you agree to publish your review (first name + initial, role). Email is never published.

Maxime Ben Bouaziz
Written by
Maxime Ben Bouaziz, CEO, Salesdorado, AI & Sales Tech

Expert in sales tools, CRM and B2B sales automation. Tests and breaks down prospecting, data enrichment and generative AI solutions to help marketing and sales teams build their stack.

Published on November 8, 2026, updated on November 16, 2026, reading 11 min