Smartlead and Instantly are two prospecting tools built specifically to run email campaigns at scale, unlike more traditional (and better-known) tools such as Lemlist, Waalaxy or La Growth Machine.
At first glance, Smartlead and Instantly have a lot in common: their lead managers and campaign editors look very much alike. But dig a little and you realize they differ on some important points.
Instantly positions itself as 3-in-1 software that includes a database for finding leads, while Smartlead focuses on campaign management and takes deliverability optimization features very far (a key issue for mass prospecting).
Our favorite? Smartlead, on balance. Here’s why.
Smartlead vs Instantly at a glance
Smartlead: our analysis in brief

Smartlead is clearly the one we prefer of the two. It’s very powerful software, specially designed for companies and agencies that need to run email campaigns at very large scale, from tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of emails per month.
Its big strength is the quality of its features for optimizing campaign deliverability: management of an unlimited number of sending addresses, smart warmup, advanced tests and analysis tools…
Everything is built to ensure the highest possible deliverability, and it works. The interface is also very intuitive and easy to pick up. On the other hand, Smartlead has no prospect database included: you have to add the SmartProspect option, at $59 per month.
Instantly: our analysis in brief

Instantly has the merit of offering a more complete solution than Smartlead, since it combines a lead database, an emailing tool and a mini CRM. On paper it’s appealing, especially as the interface is very polished and customer support is well regarded. But dig a little and you realize Instantly lacks depth and flexibility in each of its modules.
The database is very limited on the French market. The campaign editor is fairly basic. And the CRM is too rudimentary for its price. In the end, you get a tool that does a lot of things but none of them really well, and that quickly becomes limited and expensive as your needs evolve.
Smartlead vs Instantly: what their customers say
Smartlead: what customers think
Users particularly appreciate how easy the tool is to use. And there’s no denying it: the interface is intuitive and well designed overall. Customers also highlight the performance of the warmup features, which really do optimize deliverability rates.
Other strengths: the wealth of resources available (help center, online university) and the very active Slack community where users help each other.
On the downside, a few users mention technical bugs (campaign interruptions, lost lead categories…). Others regret that customer support is somewhat limited on the entry plans.
Instantly: what customers think
Instantly’s strong points from its customers’ point of view:
- Ease of use and a friendly interface, appreciated by beginners and more experienced users alike.
- Customer support also wins unanimous praise (we didn’t get the chance to test it…).
The main criticisms concern email quotas that many customers consider too low, and prices that climb fast, especially when you want access to advanced features.
Smartlead vs Instantly: functional scope
Prospect database
Instantly
Instantly stands out from Smartlead by offering a built-in database for finding new prospects. This database now claims more than 450 million B2B contacts. Unfortunately, during our test, it held only 160,000 contacts for the French market, which is quite limited. Coverage is better on the US market.
To search for prospects, you can use fairly standard filters (job title, industry, company size…) or run a natural language search with the AI tool. It’s practical and works rather well.

Instantly can also enrich existing prospecting files by filling in missing data. But here again, results vary widely depending on the information Instantly has.
Smartlead
Unlike Instantly, Smartlead wasn’t built around a database. It now offers SmartProspect, a prospect search module with verified emails: an option at $59 per month on the Base and Pro plans, included in the Unlimited plans. We haven’t tested it. Without this module, you import your own files to create your campaigns.
The core of the tool remains the management and automation of email campaigns.
Smartlead makes it easy to import large files and clean lists (deduplication, removal of invalid addresses…) at import time. But there’s no way to segment contacts afterwards. It’s one of the tool’s weak points.
Email campaign management
Smartlead
This is clearly Smartlead’s strong point. The tool lets you use an unlimited number of sending addresses, with a smart warmup system to optimize each address’s reputation.
The campaign editor is fairly basic, centered on linear sequences with few dynamic personalization options. But where Smartlead clearly stands out is the wealth of its options for maximizing deliverability:
- Sending address rotation
- Daily sending limits per address
- Sending from unique IP servers
- Sending emails in plain text
- Address verification before sending
- Anti-spam and anti-blacklist tests…
Everything is built to let you send your campaigns in bulk (up to 500,000 emails per month on the highest plan, more on request) while minimizing the risk of your messages being filtered or marked as spam. And it works very well.

Instantly
Instantly also lets you manage an unlimited number of sending addresses and has warmup features to improve deliverability.
The tool even offers “ready-to-use” sending addresses that are already warmed up, although the value of this service is debatable (using exotic domains can hurt your image…).
On the campaign editor side, Instantly has slightly more advanced personalization options than Smartlead, with A/B testing of email subject lines, sending customized to the recipient’s email provider…

On the other deliverability levers (IP rotation, sending limits…), however, Instantly is a notch below. There are a few options, but they’re less complete and less configurable than on Smartlead.
In the end, Instantly does the job for mid-sized email campaigns. But for very large volumes, you’re better off with Smartlead, which is a little better equipped for mass prospecting.
CRM and lead management
Smartlead
Smartlead’s lead management features are relatively basic. All imported contacts are centralized in one place, with no way to segment them into lists or assign them tags.
The history of interactions with each lead can be accessed from their record, but the information is limited to campaign sending history. There are no real sales tracking fields such as lead status or opportunity value…
Smartlead does, however, offer an interesting feature for centralizing exchanges with leads, through a shared inbox: the “master inbox”. It lets you read and reply to all the emails received in response to your campaigns, and set tasks and reminders. It’s a good tool for coordinating follow-up when several people work on the same campaigns.

Instantly
Instantly goes further than Smartlead by building a mini CRM directly into its interface. You get a kanban view of your leads, with customizable statuses to track their progress through the sales cycle.
It offers some interesting features, such as a prospect scoring system based on configurable criteria (e.g. company size, contact’s authority…) or an “Instant AI” module that automatically enriches your lead records with information from the web.

But overall, this built-in CRM remains fairly rudimentary compared with dedicated tools. Above all, its most advanced features (calls, SMS, multichannel sequences, team sales reports…) are reserved for the Hyper CRM plan.
For a paid plan, you can expect more than a mini CRM… (even though Instantly’s price isn’t calculated per user: one subscription can be used by an unlimited number of users). The sales pipeline is tracked in the kanban view described above.
Reporting
Smartlead
Smartlead offers fairly standard reporting, but it covers the cold emailing KPIs well: number of emails sent, open rate, click rate, reply rate, number of leads generated…
You get an overview of performance by email address used, with figures on daily sends and replies received. It’s quite practical for monitoring the reputation of each address.
The “global analytics” report lets you track results at account level and filter data by campaign or sending address.
If you have more advanced reporting needs, we recommend exporting the data to another tool via webhooks or the API, available from the Pro plan.

Instantly
Instantly has a more complete reporting tool than Smartlead, even if there’s still room for improvement. You get a fairly standard campaign performance report (open, click and reply rates…), which you can filter by various criteria.
Instantly’s real plus is its sales performance report, which includes useful metrics such as the number of opportunities generated, the lead conversion rate, the revenue generated…
In the end, Instantly’s reporting is a good point compared with Smartlead’s. It offers a better business view, closer to what happens in the field. It doesn’t reach the power of a real BI tool, obviously, but it will do the job in most cases.

Smartlead vs Instantly: integrations
Smartlead offers connectors for the main mailboxes (Gmail, Outlook), which make it easy to add your sending addresses. There’s also a Slack integration to receive notifications about replies, and now native integrations with the main CRMs: HubSpot, Salesforce, Pipedrive and Zoho CRM.
To go further, you’ll have to go through Zapier or use the Smartlead API. Smartlead also supports webhooks, which can be a good alternative to the API for simple integrations. API and webhooks require at least the Pro plan.
For its part, Instantly also offers native integrations with CRMs (Pipedrive, Hubspot, Salesforce). For full two-way sync with HubSpot or Salesforce, Instantly refers you to its partner OutboundSync.
There’s also a Slack integration and a few nice connectors such as Google Calendar and OpenAI. Like Smartlead, Instantly offers a Zapier connector and an API; its webhooks require the Hypergrowth plan.

In short, the two tools are now about even on native integrations, CRMs included. And in both cases, more specific needs will go through a third-party tool like Zapier or through the API.
Smartlead vs Instantly: pricing
Smartlead offers 4 pricing plans:
- Base at $39/month: up to 2,000 contacts and 6,000 emails/month, unlimited warmup.
- Pro at $94/month: up to 30,000 contacts and 90,000 emails/month, access to the CRM, API and webhooks.
- Unlimited Smart at $174/month: unlimited contacts, 150,000 emails/month, 50,000 verified prospect emails (SmartProspect) included.
- Unlimited Prime at $379/month: unlimited contacts, 500,000 emails/month, 170,000 verified prospect emails and 3 white-label client workspaces included.
Paying annually saves 17% on all plans.

Smartlead’s big advantage is that there’s no limit on the number of users, whichever plan you choose. You can use the tool with your whole team at no extra cost. Agencies can add white-label client workspaces from the Pro plan, for $29 per client per month.
Instantly splits its offers into separate subscriptions:
- Outreach ($47 to $358/month), which gives access to campaign and lead management, reporting, etc. (the functional scope of Smartlead, in fact): Growth at $47 (5,000 emails and 1,000 contacts), Hypergrowth at $97 (125,000 emails and 25,000 contacts), Light Speed at $358 (500,000 emails and 100,000 contacts).
- Instantly Credits ($47 to $197/month and up), which open access to the database with a monthly credit quota that varies with the plan you choose.
- The CRM, whose advanced features (calls, SMS, team reporting) are reserved for the Hyper CRM plan.
Instantly also sells bundles that combine sending and credits: Starter at $94, Scale at $194 and Agency at $555 per month. Paying annually saves about 20%.

Instantly’s split offering is a bit complex, and it’s easy to get lost… For example, to get a decent monthly lead quota and advanced CRM features, you have to combine three subscriptions: Outreach for sending, credits for the database and Hyper CRM.
By comparison, Smartlead looks simpler: one subscription, with CRM access from the Pro plan. It’s cheaper at entry level ($39 versus $47). At $97, however, Instantly Hypergrowth sends more emails (125,000) than Smartlead Pro at $94 (90,000). Smartlead regains the advantage at high volumes: 150,000 emails and unlimited contacts at $174, while Instantly jumps to $358.
Fortunately, both tools offer a 14-day free trial with no credit card, so you can get an idea before committing. Our advice: list your needs and test each software with precise goals in mind to see which one meets them best. Happy comparing!