Email marketing

Cold email prospecting statistics

Only 23.9% of prospecting emails are opened according to Gartner, and 8.5% get a reply according to Backlinko's study of 12 million emails.

Maxime Ben Bouaziz
CEO Salesdorado
July 3, 2023, updated November 16, 2026, 7 min read
Dock d’un Mac avec l’icône de l’application Mail et trois messages non lus
★ CE QU'IL FAUT RETENIR
  • Campaigns with fewer than 200 prospects get a reply rate more than twice as high: these are handcrafted campaigns.
  • The number one driver of opens is the prospect recognizing the sender; only 33% of buyers open an email based on the subject line.
  • 80% of emails are opened on mobile: keep the experience and the call to action very simple.
  • Send at least 3 follow-up emails spaced several days apart. Just one extra follow-up can already increase the reply rate by 65.8%.
  • Without an offer that interests the prospect, no optimization will get them to reply.

We went through close to twenty recent studies on prospecting emails to build this article. Most of them are well worth reading, by the way, and we cite each one throughout the article.

These studies still have an annoying habit of focusing on trivial micro-details (emojis in the subject line, for example), but they do bury a few myths and bring out some key points about what actually works.

The most telling statistic, in my view, comes from a Woodpecker study (a cold mailing tool). It dates from 2017, but it shows something that will always hold true. Campaigns with fewer than 200 prospects get a reply rate more than 2x higher than campaigns with more than 200 prospects.

Not for technical reasons. Not even for management reasons. Simply because they are not the same kind of campaign. Below 200 prospects, it is handcrafted work, with a relevant value proposition and a carefully worked audience / message pairing. Above that, it is (very) often a “Spray & Pray” campaign where you fire at everything you can and keep your fingers crossed.

The ideal, obviously, is to send more than 200 emails while staying relevant every single time.

Find the right providerNeed to outsource your prospecting? Find the provider that matches your actual needs

Find a provider

4 figures to maximize your open rates

1. Only 23.9% of prospecting emails are opened

According to a Gartner study, not even a quarter of your prospecting emails get opened. The figures from the Quickmail survey add more detail:

email reply statistics

Source: Quickmail

  • The average open rate for unsolicited emails is 44%.
  • 8% of cold email campaigns have an open rate of 80% or more.
  • About ⅓ of campaigns have an open rate of 60% or more.
  • 20% of campaigns have an open rate below 20% – a sign that they are landing in the “spam” folder.

2. 80% of buyers prefer to be contacted by email

Rain looked into prospects’ preferred contact methods. The answer is clear-cut: 80% of them back email.

Rain contact statistics

Source RAIN

Digging further, 59% of prospects prefer an email to a LinkedIn InMail (even though you can get very good results with LinkedIn prospecting!)

Go furtherDon’t overlook multichannel prospecting sequences.

3. Only 33% of buyers open an email based on the subject line

There are countless hacks, tricks and tips of every kind for boosting your email open rates with a good subject line.

email open statistics

Source: Superoffice

The thing to remember is that, whatever happens, the prospect recognizing the sender (company name, or your name) is the number one driver of opens.

33% means that 2 prospects out of 3 don’t read the subject line before opening, and so probably never read it at all.

The Salesdorado tipIf the prospect doesn’t know you, you can use a mutual connection (provided it is true & legitimate) in the subject line to create closeness. It works very well, as it happens. Example: “On behalf of XYZ”. You write in your own name, and the prospect doesn’t know you, but if they know XYZ they will very probably open it.

If that is not the case, a subject line seen as relevant can make up for the recipient never having heard of you, but it is always less effective.

subject lines with or without numbers

Source: YesWare

If anything, one good tip: including numbers in the subject line, provided they are impactful and defensible, can double the open rate.

On the other hand, all the tricks like including the prospect’s name, phrasing the subject as a question, etc. only bring a very marginal increase in open rate. Not to mention the hacks about putting emojis or keywords in your email subject lines.

  • About 10% higher open rate for an email subject line that includes a question
  • 7% higher open rate for an email subject line that includes the word “increase” …

A Superoffice study compares the open rate of an email with or without the prospect’s name in the subject line – which gives 22.6% VS 22.09%. In other words, no impact.

subject lines with the recipient's name

Source: Superoffice

They also say that a subject line with the name of a film or a song gets 26% on average … In short, either you have a good subject line – for example, you can draw on our 40 punchy prospecting email subject lines – and go for it, or you don’t and shouldn’t waste too much time on it, because it doesn’t make a huge difference.

4. 80% of opened emails are opened on mobile

According to a Campaign Monitor study, more than three quarters of your prospecting emails are opened on mobile.

open rate by device

Source: Superoffice

The Salesdorado tipIf there is only one thing to remember, it is how much it matters to keep the experience as simple as possible, with a very simple call to action.

For example, if you ask the reader to click a link that requires logging into an application with a username & password to see what you want them to see, you have lost before you start. 80% of the times your email gets opened. Ouch.

If you want to show something, put it in the email. If you want to reference something, use a simple & discreet link.

5 figures to maximize your reply rates

If you want better reply rates, there is no beating around the bush: you have to work on your offer – which is why we give you a few tips for writing the perfect prospecting email.

If what you propose in your emails is of no interest to your prospects – for example a one-hour demo of your solution to a problem they don’t have – you can optimize all you want, nobody will reply.

That is in fact the clearest point in Backlinko’s analysis of 12 million prospecting emails: the emails that talk about link exchanges or guest posts are the ones with the highest reply rates. They are very probably also the ones with the clearest value proposition.

Brian Dean is also surprised in that article that emails offering to sponsor content (i.e. to buy) get a high reply rate. We are not: buying is often a fairly attractive value proposition.

Without going as far as buying – especially if you want to sell – it is the offer and the value proposition of your outreach that will generate replies. What we present here are only optimization levers.

5. Only 8.5% of prospecting emails get a reply

A simple figure from Backlinko: fewer than 10% of prospecting emails get a reply. And they are not the only ones saying so: Moz gets a reply rate of about 8%.

email reply rates

Source: Backlinko

6. Following up triples reply rates

Sending personalized prospecting emails to a well-segmented target is an excellent start. However, your potential customers deal with a huge number of emails every day and very often miss your proposal, even if it could interest them.

woodpecker email follow-up

Woodpecker, an email prospecting tool we list among the best cold mailing tools, explains that campaigns with 1 to 3 emails in a sequence have a lower reply rate (9%) and that campaigns with 4 to 7 emails in a sequence have a reply rate three times higher (27%).

Follow-ups are there to remind your prospects that you have already tried to reach them, but that they may have been too busy to reply the first time. That does not mean, though, that you should flood your prospects’ inboxes with as many follow-ups as possible until they break and reply.

Always send at least 3 follow-up emails, spaced several days apart. The best way to make sure of that is to use an email automation tool like Woodpecker or Lemlist.

While sending 3 or more messages gives the best overall reply rate, sending just one extra follow-up can increase the reply rate by 65.8%.

multiply reply rates

Source: Backlinko

Go furtherSee our best tips for following up with a prospect by email.

7. Diversifying your points of contact doubles your reply rates

Compared with a single contact, emailing several contacts improves reply rates by 93%.

email to several contacts

Source: Backlinko

If you are reaching out to a blog run by a single author, you probably don’t need to worry about messaging several different contacts.

On the other hand, messaging several contacts matters when you are reaching out to large websites with dozens of employees. It can be hard to know who is in charge of which task: by multiplying contacts, you multiply your chances of reaching the person who can answer your request.

8. Working on your signature can have a marginal impact on your reply rates

Prospecting emails containing links to social profiles have a reply rate 9.8% higher than emails without them – links to Instagram and LinkedIn seem to be the most effective.

links to social networks

Source: Backlinko

A caveat, though: the presence of social media links usually indicates a more polished professional signature, which overall inspires more trust.

prospecting email signature

Source: Backlinko

The Salesdorado tipThe key point here is ultimately pretty basic: you have to stack the odds in your favor and take care of every aspect of the email.

9. The day of the week and the time of sending matter fairly little

Several industry studies have tried to answer the question of the “best day to send emails”. However, most of these studies focus specifically on marketing emails (newsletters, etc.).

They also tend to focus on open rates, not on reply rates.

day of the week prospecting email

Source: Backlinko

The Backlinko study essentially showed 2 things:

  • There is very little variance between days of the week (not statistically significant),
  • The weekend performs slightly worse than weekdays, unsurprisingly.

Go furtherSee our best tips on email prospecting:

The questions we get over and over.

What is the average open rate of a prospecting email?

According to a Gartner study, only 23.9% of prospecting emails are opened. The Quickmail survey gives an average open rate of 44% for unsolicited emails, with 20% of campaigns below 20%, a sign that they land in the spam folder.

What is the average reply rate of a prospecting email?

According to Backlinko, only 8.5% of prospecting emails get a reply. Moz gets a reply rate of about 8%.

How many follow-ups should you send after a prospecting email?

At least 3 follow-up emails, spaced several days apart. According to Woodpecker, campaigns with 4 to 7 emails have a reply rate of 27%, versus 9% for those with 1 to 3 emails.

Does putting the prospect's name in the subject line increase the open rate?

No. A Superoffice study gives a 22.6% open rate with the prospect's name in the subject line versus 22.09% without. Including impactful, defensible numbers in the subject line, on the other hand, can double the open rate.

What is the best day to send a prospecting email?

The Backlinko study shows very little variance between days of the week. The weekend performs slightly worse than weekdays.

★ The conversation, 0 comments

What the community says.

Basic Markdown, moderated within 24 h
Loading…

    Read next