Sales prospecting

Renting or buying an email list: where, how and from whom?

Renting an email list hands the design and sending of the campaign to the agency, at a lower cost per email, without you keeping the data. Buying leaves you in control of the list and how you use it, but the data expires fast: a list is 33% wrong after 12 months. Before sending, clean the list and check that your emailing tool accepts purchased databases.

Maxime Ben Bouaziz
CEO Salesdorado
February 1, 2022, updated November 16, 2026, 9 min read
Vieilles enveloppes timbrées en éventail, dont une enveloppe à fenêtre du War & Navy Departments
★ CE QU'IL FAUT RETENIR
  • Renting: the agency designs and sends the campaign, the cost per email is lower, but you don’t keep the data.
  • Buying: the list is yours and reusable, but it expires fast and the cost per email sent is higher.
  • Three criteria to judge a list: the type of addresses (generic or personal), the data available and the age of the list.
  • Run the list through a cleaning tool before sending and ask for a refund on addresses that bounce.
  • B2C databases sold as “opt-in” are legally unusable under the GDPR.

Often criticized, buying and renting email lists remain very effective for launching a prospecting campaign. It’s fast, cheap and has the advantage of delivering results quickly.

Still wary of using this method? In this article you’ll find why it’s worth it and how to set it up.

A gift from SalesdoradoSalesdorado helps you get this type of list and launch your campaigns quickly!

Our free company lists

SalesdoradoSimulate your choice of enrichment tool
Free tool, 2 minutes
Simulate your choice of enrichment tool

Answer 10 targeted questions and find the tools that actually fit your situation.

12
tools analyzed
10
targeted questions
€0
no sign-up
Methodology published by the Salesdorado editorial team

Should you buy or rent an email list?

Bronze statuette of Rodin’s Thinker in front of a white brick wall

There are several differences between these two options, the main one being control over the data:

  • Renting a list: the agency renting out the list usually takes care of designing and sending the campaign.
  • Buying a list: you buy a list of email addresses without much control over where these addresses come from or their quality, but you can be the sole master of how you use them: campaign, segmentation and targeting, sequencing…

Buying a list:

Pros

  • The list is yours, so you can reuse the contacts endlessly.
  • You have the additional information on each contact.

Cons

  • The cost per email sent is higher.

Renting lists:

Pros

  • The cost per email sent is lower.
  • The data was updated recently. Since the agency wants to maximize deliverability, it will make sure the email addresses are as recent as possible. That’s not always the case when it sells a list.

Cons

  • You won’t be able to reuse the list, or keep the data.

Watch outWhen you buy, you can (and should) always get a refund for email addresses that bounce. If you get high bounce rates, your deliverability will still take a hit, so we strongly recommend cleaning purchased lists before sending, while still asking for a refund on unusable rows.

Renting an email list: how it works

Red and white For Rent sign stuck behind a shop window

The email list rental process is usually fairly standardized and involves a publisher, an agency, and an advertiser (you).

  1. The email address is collected by a publisher (typically a trade media outlet) when someone signs up for a contest, an online estimate, a quote request, etc. If you’re interested in the topic, we’ve listed nearly 50 lead generation strategies in our dedicated article.
  2. The advertiser contacts an email list rental agency with a more or less detailed brief, at the very least an audience and a message.
  3. The agency contacts publishers likely to have an email list that matches the need, and agrees on a price, terms of use, etc.
  4. The agency enriches and cleans the databases. We’ve also put together an article on the best B2B data enrichment solutions.
  5. The agency designs the prospecting campaign (email templates, landing page, sequencing, multichannel when relevant, etc.)
  6. It then sends the campaign to the rented email lists, and handles reporting, including calculating the ROI.

Buying an email list: how to choose your emailing list?

Open metal filing cabinet drawer full of index cards

When you buy, the agency “just” gathers a database of emails matching your segments, and normally cleans and enriches it.

The advantage is that you control steps 5 and 6, and you can flexibly decide to add LinkedIn messages or a phone campaign, for example.

The drawback is that a list of business emails generated at a given moment loses its shine very quickly. If we assume people stay in the same job for 3 years on average, your list is 33% wrong after 12 months. 17% after 6 months.

Prospecting data expires very fast, which is why these lists are often said to be “poor quality”. In reality, the idea that you can extract emails in bulk and use them for a few weeks or months is pretty questionable in 2022.

For this reason, it’s better to build continuous lead generation and enrichment processes. But you’re probably thinking you have to start somewhere, and you’re right.

Go furtherCheck out our article on buying prospecting lists if you want to learn more!

What criteria should you use to evaluate an email list?

There are mainly 3 criteria for evaluating the quality of an email list:

  1. The type of email addresses: are they generic email addresses (contact@salesdorado.com) or personal ones (maxime@salesdorado.com)? Generic emails expire much less and much more slowly than personal emails. And for very small businesses, they’re almost always forwarded to the owner’s personal inbox. On the other hand, if you’re targeting larger companies, generic email addresses are useless, so you’re “forced” to rely on personal email addresses, with all the quality risks that implies.
  2. The data points available: does the list also include LinkedIn profiles? First and last names? Job titles? Not only will this data help you personalize your prospecting emails, it will also let you gauge the quality of the list, and so protect yourself to some extent before sending.
  3. The age of the list: list sellers and renters are rarely transparent on this point. Or they’ll flat out tell you the list was updated yesterday, which will of course be false. But asking the question can help you get an idea.

Emailing lists and deliverability: the boxes to check before buying

Orange sticky notes arranged in columns on a desk, next to a keyboard and a marker

There are several risks to consider before buying an email list.

First, you need to pay attention to the quality of the email addresses in the lists. It’s not unusual for these lists to have low deliverability, meaning that many emails get blocked by providers, end up in spam, or that the addresses no longer exist.

In that case, you’ll have bought a faulty list, and your campaign won’t perform. Push your provider as hard as you can before buying, so they prove the quality of the email list to you.

Next, to protect their image, some emailing services refuse to send emails to databases bought online. In that case, you have no chance of launching your campaign using purchased lists. So make sure your emailing service tolerates this kind of practice!

Finally, keep in mind that a poorly targeted campaign will damage your company’s image, and future emails sent from your IP address may be treated as spam. So make sure you work on the quality of your prospecting campaign before launching it.

Go furtherTo learn more about this before you start, read our email deliverability guide.

How to use an emailing list?

Blue question mark on a pink background

1. Clean your email list

We can’t say it enough: don’t rely on the list seller to guarantee the quality and freshness of the email addresses sold. The best way to handle that is to run your list through an email address cleaning tool. Here’s our guide to cleaning your customer database.

There are plenty of them, but we almost always use and recommend ZeroBounce, which offers the best value for money in our view.

1 bis. Enrich your email list (optional)

To get more out of your performance, you can enrich your contact database. We offer a summary of data enrichment best practices.

To personalize your campaigns and refine your segments, you can enrich your list with tools like Societeinfo or Clearbit. It comes at a real cost, but the performance gap is such that we recommend it fairly often.

To give you an idea, Societeinfo starts at €39 for 300 credits, and €99 for 1,000 credits. If you’re not planning to spam the entire planet, the extra cost stays reasonable, and is well worth it.

2. Prepare your prospecting campaign

This is the most important step for getting good performance. It means preparing the message you’ll put in front of each of your segments.

You can keep it simple with a fairly basic prospecting email sequence, or go much further if you have some experience with the topic, by adding other channels: LinkedIn, phone, SMS, mail… be creative!

A gift from SalesdoradoHere’s a hand: three articles that will help you build an effective prospecting campaign!

3. Send the emails

Sending the emails is a real challenge in itself, not to be overlooked. Your emails are, concretely, unsolicited emails. Some would go as far as calling them spam. We call it spam when it’s done badly, it depends on who you ask.

Either way, the main emailing software like Sendinblue or Activecampaign won’t let you blast your campaign. Some say Hubspot allows it, but it could damage the reputation of your nurturing and marketing emails, which you really don’t want.

Fortunately, there are tools designed specifically for sending cold emails and we’ve put together a step-by-step guide to sending your prospecting emails without damaging your reputation.

Salesdorado’s adviceThink seriously about the volume of emails you can send and the number of leads you can handle before buying your list. No point buying a 40,000-row list if you can only send 100 emails a day and/or handle 10 leads a day: if your campaign runs for several months, your data will be increasingly wrong and your performance increasingly poor.

4. Reporting & ROI calculation

All that’s left is to measure performance, optimize and iterate. Using an email list is a good way to test a market, launch a campaign and get started.

Once you start getting responses, we encourage you to look into outbound lead generation methods to build lead generation flows and work with fresher leads.

Who should you buy an emailing list from?

Wooden cabinet with small drawers fitted with label holders

Not all list sellers are at the same level. Broadly speaking, keep these three options in mind:

  1. Prospecting agencies: these are agencies specialized in sales prospecting, offering all-in-one services. They usually have real data expertise that lets them get excellent performance. We’ve selected the 10 best prospecting agencies on the market.
  2. “Traditional” list sellers: while they often have a fairly bad reputation for aggressive sales practices, they can give real advice on designing your segments, and help you design your campaigns. We’ve written a complete comparison of list providers.
  3. Prospecting software: the overall leader in France is Societeinfo, but there are quite a few new entrants on the subject, such as Pharow, which does a great job of simplifying these topics. If you want to prospect abroad, look at apollo.io, which offers a real prospecting platform with a lot of fairly high-quality data. Otherwise the leader in B2B data is Clearbit, but they charge leader prices, around 10 cents per row, for a Do It Yourself experience.

Buying an opt-in B2C email list: a scam?

Red traffic light lit against a black background

Clearly, yes. It makes no sense. Opt-in means the user of the email address in question agreed to receive emails. In practice it’s often the “I agree that partners of so-and-so may contact me” box on big consumer websites.

But on a fairly close reading of the GDPR, the user must be clearly informed of the identity of the companies their email address will be passed on to.

If someone sells you “opt-in” databases, they’re “opted in” for something other than the use you’ll make of them, so they’re legally unusable.

Above all, let’s be honest, nobody will read your emails. For us, it’s a red flag.

Go furtherWe’ve written other articles to help you with every type of prospecting!

The questions we get over and over.

Should you rent or buy an email list?

The main difference is control over the data. When renting, the agency usually handles designing and sending the campaign, the cost per email is lower but you can neither reuse the list nor keep the data. When buying, the list is yours and you decide how to use it, but the cost per email sent is higher.

How long does a B2B email list stay usable?

Not long. If we assume people stay in the same job for 3 years on average, a list is 33% wrong after 12 months and 17% wrong after 6 months.

What criteria should you use to evaluate an email list?

The type of email addresses (generic or personal), the data points available (LinkedIn profiles, first and last names, job title) and the age of the list.

Can you send to a purchased list with standard emailing software?

Often not: to protect their image, some emailing services refuse to send emails to purchased databases. There are tools designed for sending cold emails.

Is buying an opt-in B2C email list a scam?

Yes. Under the GDPR, the user must be informed of the identity of the companies their address will be passed on to. An “opt-in” database is opted in for something other than the use you’ll make of it, so it’s legally unusable.

★ The conversation, 0 comments

What the community says.

Basic Markdown, moderated within 24 h
Loading…

    Read next